Mesh or wired access points? Notes from three flats
Mesh kits are convenient, but a single Ethernet run can matter more than the brand on the box. What I learned setting up three very different flats.
Over the past couple of years I've helped set up Wi-Fi in three flats: a long, narrow two-room flat in an old brick building, a modern open-plan studio, and a three-room flat with concrete interior walls. Here is what I'd do again and what I wouldn't.
The brick flat: mesh worked well
The router lived by the front door, and the bedroom at the far end got a weak, unreliable signal. Running cable wasn't an option. A two-unit mesh kit with a dedicated 5 GHz backhaul radio fixed it. The trick was placement: the second unit had to go roughly halfway, where it still had a strong link to the router, not in the bedroom itself. Placing the satellite where the signal is already bad just relays a bad signal.
The studio: one good router was enough
The owner had bought a three-piece mesh kit for 35 square metres. The units spent most of their time interfering with each other. We turned two of them off, moved the main unit from a cupboard to an open shelf, and speeds went up. More access points aren't automatically better.
The concrete flat: cable won
Wireless backhaul couldn't get through two concrete walls reliably. We ran a single flat Ethernet cable along the skirting board to the far room and connected the second unit by wire. Performance in that room went from unusable to the same as next to the router. A wired backhaul is simply a different league from a wireless one.
Rules of thumb
- If you can run even one cable, use it for the link between access points.
- Place a wireless mesh satellite where the signal is still good, not where it's bad.
- Small spaces rarely need more than one well-placed access point.
- Measure in each room before and after. Feelings are unreliable; numbers aren't.